top of page
Why You Should Forget About Fixed, Indexed, and Variable Annuities—And Focus Exclusively on DIAs for Retirement Income

When it comes to retirement planning, annuities are often promoted as a simple solution for securing a steady income stream. However, not all annuities are equal, and many fall short when it comes to addressing retirees' diverse financial needs. Fixed Annuities (MYGAs), Indexed Annuities, and Variable Annuities each have inherent limitations—particularly when it comes to growing wealth. While they can offer guaranteed income, they are not the best tools for achieving meaningful growth. In contrast, Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs) stand out as an ideal solution for retirement income. By combining DIAs for reliable income with true growth strategies, retirees can create a more balanced and secure retirement plan.
 

1. Fixed Annuities (MYGAs): Safe, but Limited Growth Potential
 

Fixed annuities, such as Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs), provide predictable interest rates for a fixed term, which can offer security. However, the returns are typically low and may not keep pace with inflation, making it harder to preserve purchasing power over time. While MYGAs can be a safe option, they don’t offer significant growth opportunities, which is crucial for long-term financial health in retirement.
 

2. Indexed Annuities: Growth Isn't What It Seems
 

Indexed annuities promise the potential for higher returns linked to the performance of a stock market index, such as the S&P 500. But these products often come with caps that limit the upside you can earn and participation rates that restrict how much of the market’s growth you can access. These features can leave you frustrated when market performance exceeds the cap on your annuity. Additionally, indexed annuities can be complex, with rules and fees that make it difficult for retirees to fully benefit from the growth they are promised. While indexed annuities provide some growth potential, it is often much lower than what could be achieved through other strategies.


3. Variable Annuities: High Risk and High Fees
 

Variable annuities provide exposure to market performance through a selection of sub-accounts, but they come with notable risks and costs. The returns depend on the market, so there is the potential for loss if the market declines. Additionally, variable annuities are notorious for their high fees, which can erode returns over time. This combination of market risk and high costs makes variable annuities a less appealing option for retirees seeking stability and simplicity in their retirement strategy.


4. The Case for Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs): The Best Choice for Secure Retirement Income
 

While many annuities fall short on growth, Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs) are designed specifically for providing guaranteed, predictable income. DIAs work by converting a lump sum into a stream of income that starts at a later date, offering a level of security that no other annuity type can match.
 

  • Predictable, Lifelong Income: Once you purchase a DIA and defer the start date, you’ll know exactly how much money you will receive each month (or year) for the rest of your life. This level of certainty is rare in retirement planning.
     

  • No Market Volatility: Unlike variable or indexed annuities, DIAs are not affected by market swings, so you can rely on them for stable income regardless of what’s happening in the stock market.
     

  • Maximizing Income Efficiency: DIAs are among the most efficient ways to secure income in retirement. Due to mortality credits and interest rate factors, DIAs often offer a higher payout than traditional bonds or CDs, giving you more income for your savings.


5. The Perfect Complement: DIAs for Income, True Growth Strategies for Wealth
 

While DIAs excel at providing secure, predictable retirement income, they are not designed to grow wealth. For that, truegrowth strategies could make more sense, such as low-cost funds or Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs). These options provide a way to capture broader market growth without the complexity, high costs, or restrictions associated with other annuities. By keeping costs low and diversifying across a wide range of assets, these growth strategies can offer a path to wealth accumulation over time.
 

It could make sense to pair the security of DIAs for income with true growth strategies like low-cost ETFs or index funds for wealth accumulation. This approach allows retirees to ensure their income is secure while still pursuing the growth needed to keep up with inflation and increasing retirement expenses.
 

Conclusion: Forget About the Other Annuities—Focus on DIAs for Income
 

While fixed, indexed, and variable annuities may be suitable for certain objectives, they often fall short in providing the right balance of income and growth needed for a successful retirement. DIAs, on the other hand, are specifically designed to deliver reliable income, making them one of the best solutions for securing your retirement. When paired with true growth strategies like low-cost ETFs or funds, DIAs can help provide income security with a portion of your portfolio, while the rest of it can enjoy long-term wealth regeneration and accumulation.
 

Ultimately, retirement is about more than just choosing a single product. It’s about creating a holistic plan that secures your income while addressing your broader financial goals. For guaranteed, predictable income, DIAs stand out as the most effective tool—complemented by growth strategies that help ensure your retirement lasts as long as you do.

National Annuity Educators – Trusted Annuity Income Planning Resource

© 2025 National Annuity Educators |  All Right Reserved

Website Disclaimer for National Annuity Educators (NAE)
 

The information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and is intended solely for the benefit of individuals who are approaching retirement or are already in retirement. National Annuity Educators (NAE) does not provide investment, tax, or legal advice, and nothing on this site should be interpreted as such. The content provided, including articles, guides, and other materials, is intended to help individuals better understand retirement planning concepts, including annuities, but is not designed to offer specific recommendations for individual financial situations. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, NAE makes no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of the content on this site. The information provided may be subject to change and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional advice. NAE does not guarantee any outcomes, financial success, or results from implementing any of the strategies, concepts, or information discussed on this site. Before making any financial decisions or taking action based on the content on this website, we strongly recommend consulting with a qualified and licensed financial professional, such as a financial planner, tax advisor, or attorney, who can consider your individual circumstances and provide personalized advice. NAE does not endorse or recommend any specific financial products, services, or strategies. All references to the safety and guarantees of annuities, including any claims related to guaranteed income, returns, or protection from market loss, are subject to the claims-paying ability of the underlying annuity company. Annuities are backed solely by the financial strength of the insurance company that issues them, and NAE does not make any promises, warranties, or representations regarding the performance of any specific annuity product or the ability of the insurance company to fulfill its obligations under the contract. Additionally, the content on this site may reference potential benefits of annuities, including the possibility of guaranteed income, but such benefits are contingent upon the terms of the specific annuity contract. NAE makes no representations beyond what is explicitly guaranteed by the underlying annuity carrier in the terms of their legal policy contract. Any guarantees or safety features discussed should be viewed as specific to the contract terms and not as an endorsement or prediction of financial results. By using this website, you agree that NAE is not liable for any financial loss or damage resulting from the use or reliance on any content or information provided on the site. Always do your own research and consult with professionals before making any financial decisions. National Annuity Educators is not an insurance company, financial institution, or a licensed advisor. The information provided here is designed solely for general educational purposes and should not be construed as advice or a substitute for professional services. 

Copyright and Intellectual Property Notice
 

All content on this website, including but not limited to articles, guides, videos, graphics, logos, and educational materials, is the exclusive intellectual property of National Annuity Educators (NAE) and is protected by copyright laws. This content is provided for educational purposes to help consumers better understand retirement planning and annuities. NAE grants users permission to view, access, and use the educational materials on this site solely for personal, non-commercial purposes. Unauthorized copying, reproduction, distribution, or dissemination of any materials found on this site, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited. Additionally, agents, advisors, or any third parties are expressly prohibited from using, copying, or distributing any of the content on this website without the prior written consent of NAE. The content is intended solely for consumer education and should not be repurposed or utilized in any commercial or advisory context without explicit permission. All trademarks, service marks, and logos displayed on the site are the property of NAE or their respective owners and may not be used without prior authorization. By using this site, you agree to respect and comply with these intellectual property terms. Any unauthorized use of NAE's content may result in legal action. For inquiries regarding permission to use or distribute any content from this website, please contact National Annuity Educators directly for express written consent.

bottom of page