Annuities Are Not Complicated or Complex — Until You Try to Make Them Something They’re Not
One of the things we hear time and time again from both consumers and non-annuity financial professionals alike is that annuities are complex, extremely difficult to understand, and therefore should generally be avoided as viable financial products.
In this article, we’re going to pull back the curtain on this belief and give you a transparent set of tools and an educational framework that simplifies annuities down to a ridiculously easy level of understanding and use.
For Over 2,000 Years, Annuities Were Simple
Since the Romans came up with the concept of lifetime pension style annuities in approximately 136 B.C., the concept was refreshingly simple.
You give an institution money. In exchange, they guarantee you income — for life. End of story.
That’s it.
-
No fancy indexes.
-
No crediting methods.
-
No volatility-controlled rebalancing algorithms.
-
No fees.
-
No 83-page contracts.
-
And definitely no ancient Fishermen rambling on about “Odimus Annua” – which we are pretty sure is Latin for “We Hate Annuities…” (Haha, sorry we couldn’t help ourselves)
Just predictable, guaranteed income. Simple. Elegant. Useful.
So… what happened?
Enter the Era of Complexity
About 30–50 years ago, financial firms realized something: People love income guarantees — but they also love growth.
So the insurance industry got to work creating products that could supposedly deliver both.
Thus began the rise of variable annuities and later indexed annuities — packed with investment options, crediting strategies, bonus roll-ups, spread rates, participation percentages, more moving parts than a NASA schematic - oh and fees, fees, and more fees. Fees for every little feature you might want to add into the mixture.
But here’s the truth: Most of the confusion around annuities exists only because we started asking them to do things they were never built to do.
Annuities were always meant to provide guaranteed income, not mimic the stock market.
The Swiss Army Knife Problem
What we have now is a generation of “Swiss Army knife” annuities — trying to be part CD/bond, part mutual fund, part pension, and part lottery ticket.
They’re marketed as all-in-one solutions… but like most tools that try to do everything, they don’t do any one thing particularly well.
It’s no different than those holiday gag gifts you see every December pop up in Cyber Monday stocking stuffer ads for Dad — a “Mini Swiss Army hammer” with a hammer head on one end and 37 fold-out tools on the other end that’s more toy than tool.
No legitimate construction company would attempt to build a house with one.
The pros use real individual tools for specific jobs.
The financial industry has gone down the same path:
-
The insurance industry is trying to look like the stock market.
-
The securities industry is trying to offer downside protection like insurance.
Just look at the rise of things like buffered ETFs and RILAs (Registered Indexed-Linked Annuities).
Layers on layers. Complexity on complexity. Fees on more fees. It’s getting ridiculous.
Simplicity Returns When You Use Annuities for What They’re Good At
The solution? Stop using annuities for growth and start using them for income.
When you strip away the exotic index crediting methods, fee layers, and endless fine print, and instead focus on guaranteed income — annuities become radically simple again.
Especially when you use guaranteed income annuities (like deferred income annuities or fixed indexed annuities with simple income riders):
-
You know exactly how much income you’ll get.
-
You know when it starts.
-
You know it’s guaranteed for life.
That’s it. One dimension. Pure income. No games.
And perhaps the best part of all – properly designed lifetime income annuities, in all their simple beauty, can legitimately produce 20-60% higher annual income than most conventional retirement income methods, while requiring much less capital to do it with!
Do you realize what that last sentence actually means? It means more often than not, you can solve all your lifetime income needs on a contractually guaranteed basis and it usually only requires about HALF your portfolio to do it with!
Why Simplicity Matters
The famous quote by Leonardo da Vinci says it best: “Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication.”
In retirement, that couldn’t be more true.
You don’t need more complexity — you need more certainty.
You don’t need a Swiss Army hammer — you need the right tool for the job.
A Few Easy Rules of Thumb To Cut Through the Noise and Enjoy the Simplicity Annuities Can Provide
-
Don't use annuities to grow lump sum capital. (That alone helps avoid 90% of the overly complicated annuity products on the market today.)
-
Use annuities for lifetime retirement income and stability. That’s it.
-
Stick to lifetime income annuities based entirely on contractual guarantees — not hypothetical performance tied to an underlying stock index.
Just buy contractual guarantees. Just buy lifetime income. It's that simple.
The Simple But Powerful Retirement Income and Preservation Plan That’s Almost Hard to Believe
How about a real life practicable scenario to test out just how simple things can be:
Scenario: 65-Year-Old With $1 Million
Traditional stock market strategy (4% rule):
-
Risk the entire $1 million for $40,000/year of income.
-
Cross your fingers, hold your breath, and pray for nothing to go horribly wrong during the next 20+ years.
Vs.
Alternative: Time-Segmented Annuity-Based Plan Using The Same $1 Million
-
Step 1: $657,000 into a guaranteed lifetime income annuity = $50,000/year (25% more income using 34% less capital)
-
Step 2: $78,000 into a 10-year deferred income annuity = $12,500/year starting in year 11 (built-in 25% raise as stacked lifetime income increases to $62,500 for life)
-
Step 3: Remaining $265,000 stays in a low-cost ETF index portfolio. Assuming 8% over 20 years, it grows to $1,235,000 by age 85.
-
Step 4: Recover 120% of original principal by age 85 on top of and in addition to $62,500 per year of lifetime income still paying like clockwork from annuities.
Benefits:
-
Higher guaranteed income than the 4% rule
-
Market risk and sequence risk eliminated from income
-
Built-in income raises regardless of stock performance
-
Full preservation (and regrowth) of principal
-
No unnecessary complexity or high fees
Why does it have to be any more complicated than that?
Buy your lifetime income.
Buy your inflation adjustments to kick in whenever you want.
Invest the difference.
Done!
Bottom Line:
Annuities only seem complex when they’re forced to do things they were never designed to do.
Strip away the bells and whistles, and what’s left is one of the most simple and powerful tools for retirement income ever created.
If you’re ready to cut through the noise, avoid unnecessary risk, and see how a simple, contractually guaranteed income plan could work in your situation — schedule your complimentary strategy session today.
Let’s bring retirement income back to what it was always meant to be: simple, stable, and stress-free.